HACKENSACK − The prosecution believes that the $11,000 Daniel Rochat owed his on-again-off-again girlfriend, Christina Salito, was his motive for killing real estate agent Barbara Vernieri in September 2012.
Rochat is accused of brutally beating and setting fire to the 70-year-old Vernieri, someone he had known since childhood, on Sept. 14, 2012. He was convicted in 2017 but the decision was overturned by an appellate court in 2022.
Salito, who testified Wednesday morning, told the court the pair had met in May 2011 and they had a relationship that lasted until about January 2012. During that time, Rochat asked Salito to borrow money to pay off a credit card in August 2011.
Salito said they had multiple conversations about money because she wasn’t comfortable giving him a loan. She said she agreed to lend him the money but she would pay the credit card company directly. Salito said she wrote a $9,800 check to the credit card company.
A month later, Rochat asked to borrow $500 to help with a mechanical problem on his boat, which he promised to pay back when he got his next paycheck. In January 2012, Rochat borrowed an additional $500 but Salito said she couldn’t recall what it was for. Salito said Rochat had lost his job and was unemployed around January 2012.
They mutually agreed to no longer see each other, but when Salito went on a business trip to London in March 2012, she invited Rochat along with the understanding that she would pay for half of her airfare, tours and meals and he would pay her back , which totaled $719.
In total, Rochat owed Salito $11,519 and she told the court she never indicated the money was a gift and had set up a date for Rochat to pay her back for the $9,800 she paid to the credit card company.
Following the London trip, Salito and Rochat broke up and had very minimal contact until July 2012, when Rochat invited Salito to his parents’ shore house in Toms River.
Several days before Vernieri’s death, on Sept. 10, Salito and Rochat broke up again and met up at Blondie’s Sports Bar in New York City so Rochat could return Salito’s apartment key and several other items. Salito told the court she told Rochat they weren’t fit for each other and that the outstanding debt Rochat had with her was “too uncomfortable to continue communication.”
More Bergen County news: Driver charged in double-fatal Teaneck crash to weigh plea offer
Salito said she spoke to Rochat on the phone on Sept. 11 around 7 pm and that he told her he wanted to work on himself and move past the situation he was in and wanted to work on getting a better job and lifestyle so they could potentially communicate again.
According to Salito, she told him it was a good idea for him to work on himself to figure out what was best for him and that she would do the same but she wasn’t looking to date anyone and didn’t know if getting together was an option.
During cross-examination, Salito acknowledged that it was more than the money that led to their breakup, including her thinking at one point that Rochat was cheating on her.
Kristin Pechow, who said she met Rochat when they were children at tennis camp and reconnected in their 20s, told the court she saw Rochat the afternoon Vernieri was killed and he asked her if he could borrow $200, and asked where he could donate a pair of shoes.
Pechow said she had been dogsitting at her parents’ home in Ridgewood and she and Rochat talked on Sept. 13, 2012, about meeting later that night for a drink but mutually canceled their plans.
Instead, Pechow said she saw him the next day, Sept. 14, 2012. She couldn’t recall who he had reached out first, but she said he showed up at about 3 pm in his black pickup truck and they spent time on the back deck.
During the visit, Pechow said Rochat received a phone call and she recognized his father’s voice. She said Rochat put the phone on speaker, not something she remembers him doing before, and his father said something had happened to someone in the real estate office. Vernieri was a real estate agent at Kurgan-Bergen Realtors, partly owned by Rochat’s father, Gene.
She said they drove to Citibank on Route 17 and she withdrew $200 to lend to Rochat.
Before Rochat left, Pechow said he asked where he could donate shoes and showed her a pair of black dress shoes. She said she told him there was a restaurant with a donation bin between her parents’ home and her parents’ home.
During cross-examination, Pechow said Rochat said what had happened was horrible and he couldn’t believe it but she didn’t know he was talking about Vernieri at the time. She said the conversation happened toward the end of the visit as she was leaving to go to dinner with her aunt. When asked by Rochat’s defense attorney, Anthony Pope, whether or not she saw any scratches on Rochat when she saw him, Pechow said she didn’t see any.
Pechow noted that several days after Venieri’s killing, Rochat asked to stay at her parents’ house but she had said no. She said she had spoken to the police a day or two before but said police didn’t say that Rochat was a suspect in Vernieri’s killing but couldn’t recall what else they asked her about.
A Bergen County Prosecutor’s Office detective testified following Pechow and Salito.
The trial is expected to continue next week.
