The next remake of Harry Potter in television version by HBO Max has generated great expectations among fans of the saga, especially in terms of the reinterpretation of characters like Fred and George Weasley. The original films of Warner Bros They had to omit several nuances of the story and characters due to time constraints, a situation that could be substantially improved with the extended format of television.
Fred and George Weasley were highlighted in the books of Harry Potter As the pranksters and entrepreneurs of the saga, they provided crucial comic moments in both the books and the films. However, in the film version, James and Oliver Phelps, who played the twins, were not able to capture all the individual characteristics of each one due to the way their dialogue and scenes were written.
The main problem in the original films is that Fred and George they were largely treated as a single unit. The similarity in dialogue and the frequent synchronization of their lines created the impression that they “shared a mind.” They talked at the same time and did the same things. This resulted in their individual identities not being fully developed on screen, unlike in the books where the text clearly specified who was speaking at any given time.
In the books of JK Rowling, there are key differences between Fred and George. Fred is usually more playful and brave, even being more aggressive in certain situations, while George is more reserved and calculating. These distinctions were downplayed in the film versions. The new series of HBO has the opportunity to rectify that, offering the actors who play the twins more of their own lines and separate screen time, to better reflect their unique personalities.
One of the most criticized moments of the original films is the omission of the death scene of Fred Weasley in “Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2″. That dramatic event, as described in the books, was one of the most moving moments for readers. Fred dies while laughing at a jokewhich showed a tragic contrast to the character’s cheerful nature. “For this reason, I was outraged to see that the movie Deathly Hallows Part 2 removed the scene.”said a film critic. Instead, Fred’s body was briefly shown in the Great Hall and it was not immediately clear whether it was Fred or George who had died, again blurring his individuality.
The importance of properly reflecting the personalities and narrative arc of each twin is crucial to the success of the remake. Fans hope to see a more faithful representation of the books, where Fred and George’s individual differences are more detailed and evident. The television series has the advantage of having more time to explore these characteristics, something that could take the twins’ individuality even further than in the books.
The fact that the harry potter movies They cut and altered many of the subplots is not surprising, given the limited format of a film. However, the series HBO televisionscheduled to debut in 2026has no such limitation, giving the writers a unique opportunity to delve into the personalities and dynamics of all the characters, including Fred and George Weasley.
Throughout their participation in the original series, the Weasley twins were treated in a unified manner. “Fred and George’s shared lines were funny, but they hurt their characters”, emphasizes an article. This manifests itself in many of his interactions and banter, where they often exchanged lines or spoke in unison, simplifying their roles and making it difficult for him to develop his individuality.
With more time and space to develop detailed subplots, it is expected that the Harry Potter television remake of HBO can correct these deficiencies and give Fred and George Weasley the individuality and depth they deserve.
